My Mildest Possible Defense of "Amsterdam", and thoughts on "American Hustle"
I could write up a simple and to-the-point review of David O. Russell's newest conspiracy comedy, "Amsterdam". Like his acclaimed 2013 hit "American Hustle", this film carries a stacked cast and a thin script. It is both a passable comedy and a positively incoherent retelling of a deeply dumb criminal plot. The actors are mostly just fine, and few are given much to do, but Rami Malek as the quiet smarmy villain is good enough to single out. The sets and costumes look impressive (and expensive!). I don't think I wasted my time streaming the movie, and I even enjoyed it in spaces, but I certainly don't think it's a must see. More interesting is trying to piece together how we got to this point, for everyone involved. David O. Russell got to this point by being a deeply awful person, who has behaved rudely and even violently to the stars of about half of his films. There's the groping his niece thing, which feels well beyond the allowable degree o...